Has someone made an extensive survey of voice-leading principles?

Hello,

I hope that it is not controversial to say that there are many variations/schools regarding the voice-leading principles described in Harmony textbooks, and that there is not one "correct" method for connecting chords in common practice harmony.

I am wondering if there are any comprehensive surveys that address/quantify/compare the main guidelines ("rules") that are described in different textbooks. For example, dealing with hidden octaves/fifths (whether it ranges from FORBIDDEN to acceptable under X and Y circumstances), doubling of the notes in 4-part writing, and other aspects of voice leading that are commonly addressed in textbooks.

I am aware of David Huron's Voice Leading: The Science behind a Musical Art

Are there any other papers/books that I should be looking into?

Thank you,

Néstor

Sign In or Register to comment.